Yankees Love/Hate: April 24

Welcome to Love/Hate, where I rant about 5 things I like about the Yankees right now, and 5 I don’t. This week’s edition is sponsored by C.C.’s noodle arm.

LOVE: Brett Gardner’s peskiness. The 2013 Yankees may have lost seven of their top nine home run hitters from last year, but one thing they gained was Gardner, who is basically a poor man’s Johnny Damon at this point. Gardner has played a strong center field in Curtis Granderson’s absence (though his arm strength is reminiscent of Bernie Williams), and he has shocked me with two home runs so far this year, not all that far from his career high of seven. But Gardner’s strength will always be his speed on the bases and his gnat-like ability to stay alive at the plate.

(more…)

The 2013 Yankees: We’ve Seen This Before

A brief discourse on the 1965 Yankees:

From 1949 to 1964, the Yankees missed the playoffs three times and were indisputably the greatest dynasty in baseball history. Sure, the Braves made 14 consecutive postseasons from 1991-2005 and the current Yankees have been in the playoffs in 17 of the last 18 years (dating back to 1995, the Bombers have the missed the playoffs just once, in 2008). But the Truman-Eisenhower-JFK-LBJ dynasty existed when only one team from each league made the playoffs, and the World Series was postseason enough.

So the Yanks had won 13 pennants and nine World Series titles in 16 seasons going into 1965. But the Bombers had been living on borrowed time, relying too heavily on the fading bats of Mickey Mantle and Yogi Berra** and the aging skills of Whitey Ford. By ’65, Berra was retired, Ford was relying on guile and the Mick had the knees of a 50-year-old man. Even Elston Howard was 36 and at the tail end of his career. Of the team’s top players, only ace Mel Stottlemyre was in his prime.

**Things you learn while rifling through BaseballReference.com: Yogi Berra finished in the top four in the AL MVP voting SEVEN YEARS IN A ROW. Including three firsts and two seconds! Yogi might the all-time case of a player’s outsized personality overshadowing a historically good career (though Clyde Frazier might topple him once he’s done stylin’ and profilin’).

The ’65 Yankees were weak on paper and equally weak on the field. After winning 99 games in 1964, they went a dismal 77-85 the next season, beginning a drought of 12 years between playoff appearances. The average age of the starting lineup was 30 years old, and no regular had a better line than Tom Tresh’s .279/.348/.477. I haven’t seen an inning of game footage from that year, but the numbers say that the ’65 Yankees were a formerly great team on a slow road to the bottom.

(more…)

Game #161: Fandemonium

Fandom is…

…staying at the ballpark when it is all but certain your team is going to lose.

…watching in horror as Mark Teixeira bats ahead of Robinson Cano in the lineup and proceeds to go 0-6, stranding nine runners. In his first two at-bats, Teix came up with runners at the corners and one out. Both times, he grounded into a 6-4-3 inning-ending double play. He ended an ending by stranding two runners in each of his first three at-bats, all with Cano standing idle in the on-deck circle. I know Joe Girardi loves to play matchups, and Red Sox starter Jon Lester was a lefty, but… Teixeira should hit ahead of Cano again when hell freezes over. And not a game sooner.

…appreciating the hellacious week and a half Cano has had. In his last eight games, Robbie is 20-for-35 (.625) with a home run and eight RBIs. He’s had at least two hits in each game. Sure, his hot stretch has come against terrible teams, but a hot Cano is a nearly unstoppable Cano. Now, can he keep it up in the postseason? I say yes. Though his career postseason slash line is just .258/.307/.491, he hit .316 in the 2010 and 2011 playoffs combined, with six homers and 15 RBIs in 14 games.

…suffering gamely through one terrible at-bat with runners in scoring position after another. At one point, the Yankees had 11 hits and one run last night. For the year, the team’s RISP line is .255/.351/.431, and that’s only after a strong last month in clutch situations. Watching it inning after inning after inning is an exercise in insanity management.

…believing your team can rally in the ninth inning even though it’s 0-59 when losing after eight innings for the season.

…repeating the mantra: “A bloop and a blast” over and over again until you believe it.

…standing in expectant shock as the impossible becomes real. Until Raul Ibanez’s game-tying home run in the ninth was halfway to the right-field seats, I honestly didn’t believe it was gone.

…jumping up and down like a maniac, screaming yourself hoarse with the kind of pure, unbridled joy that is all too rare in life.

…trying valiantly to get your heart to stop racing, and failing.

…choking back bitter disappointment when a ninth-inning bid to win fails. Bases loaded, one out, all the momentum on your side, and you can’t get it done?!?! Ugh.

…settling in for the long haul of extra innings.

…believing that a third-string catcher with exactly zero at-bats on the season can find a way to get on base.

…having that faith rewarded. Thank you, Francisco Cervelli. Your season-long angst at being demoted to the minors must have been forgotten a little bit after that critical walk.

…screaming “RAUUUUUUUUULLLLLL!!!!!” like it’s your job.

…raising your arms to the heavens and bellowing (there’s no better word to describe it) as somehow, some way, your team scores the winning run to maintain a one-game division lead with one game left. Do wins get bigger? Sure. Do comebacks get more scintillating? Absolutely. But in this situation, with everything on the line, against your bitterest rival, when the Yankees’ win probability heading into the bottom of the ninth was nine percent? This was damn near perfect.

…croaking “New York, New York” because you have no voice left. And my God is that croak satisfying.

Yankees 4, Red Sox 3. One-game lead on the Orioles with one game to go. Now it’s 5-1 Yankees in the third inning. The finish line is in sight.

Game #155: Is C.C. Back?

A rare easy win for the Bombers last night — it was only the team’s second win by more than three runs since Aug. 13, a stretch of 40 games. The Yankees jumped all over hapless Twins pitcher Brian Duensing for six runs in the third inning, including an incredible THREE HITS IN A ROW WITH RUNNERS IN SCORING POSITION (the caps lock seems justified given the Yankees’ atrocious hitting with RISP this year). Handed an early 6-1 lead, C.C. Sabathia took care of the rest, shutting down the Twins over eight innings and allowing just two runs. The 8-2 win kept the Yanks 1.5 games ahead of the Orioles, who are idle Thursday.

(more…)

Game #139: Safe Is Safe

Every so often, an umpire make a call so egregious, so obviously incorrect, that it restarts the calls for more instant replay in baseball. Last night’s game-ender by Jerry Meals was one of those calls.

Mark Teixeira was safe by a mile. A blind man could have seen it. The ump was on the take. You get the idea — a brutally bad call deciding a September game in a division race. If Meals gets the call right, it’s 5-5 and Alex Rodriguez has a chance to give the Yankees the lead. Instead, it’s game over, and the Orioles have tied the Yanks atop the AL East again.

I’m for replay on all safe/out, fair/foul, and home run/not home run calls. Other than the complaints about slowing down the game (spare me, if football can do it then so can baseball), the biggest argument against more replay is that it “takes the human element out of the game.” Here’s the human element of the last play in Saturday’s 5-4 win by the Orioles: Teixeira, needing only a productive out to tie the game, hit a weak ball to second that appeared to be a tailor-made game-ending double play. Recognizing the urgency of the moment, Teix sprinted out of the box, re-injuring his left calf in the process, and slid headfirst into the bag to avoid completely blowing out the calf. He beat the throw to first by a wide margin, a valiant effort to tie a game that the Yankees really needed to win. That’s the human element of the play. In today’s digital, tech-driven world, it’s easy enough to spot when the system breaks down. But baseball has been unwilling to avail itself of that technology. So safe becomes out, and a gritty hustle play is negated as it’s happening. What’s good, or fair, or competitively honest about that?

The Yankees’ Achilles Heel

From my uncle, after the Yankees’ dispiriting 8-5 loss to the Blue Jays yesterday:

While it is nice to have Sabathia back and Andy [Pettitte] looming on the horizon…the big problem for the Yankees continues to be stranding an absurd amount of men on base.

The Yankees’ failure with runners in scoring position this season has become an albatross around the team’s neck and a sore spot for fans. The problem is simple to show statistically:

YANKEES SITUATIONAL HITTING 2012
Bases Empty: .283/.339/.476 (.815 OPS, 1st in MLB)
RISP: .251/.327/.427 (.754 OPS, 10th in MLB)
RISP w/ 2 Outs: .231/.332/.390 (.722 OPS, 17th in MLB)
Bases Loaded: .211/.255/.472 (.727 OPS, 15th in MLB)

There’s a reason the Yankees score such a high percentage of their runs off the home run. They are comparatively awful with men in scoring position, particularly with two outs or with the bases loaded. For lack of a better word, they choke.

And it’s a top-down problem for the Yankee offense. Check the OPS numbers of the Yankees’ best hitter, Robinson Cano:

Bases Empty: .916
RISP: .754
RISP w/ 2 Outs: .704
Bases Loaded: .712

Cano goes from an All-Star level hitter with no one on base (and, curiously, with just a runner on first) to a slightly below average player with RISP. The Yankees depend heavily on the top of their order, so the millstone that is Cano’s split statistics with RISP (and similar numbers for Mark Teixeira) is pretty damn heavy.

Wednesday, the Yankees went 3-17 with runners in scoring position. In the fourth inning, they loaded the bases with one out before Nick Swisher and Cano struck out. In the sixth, Jayson Nix doubled to lead off the inning, but the Yankees did not score. In the eighth, two straight doubles to start the inning cut the Toronto lead to 6-5, but the Yankees failed to score Russell Martin from second with none out.

Next time you watch the Yankees play, apply a cardinal (if somewhat anachronistic) rule of baseball to the Yanks’ offense: one out should equal one base. In other words, if you have a runner on second and no one out, you should score. If you have a runner on third and fewer than two outs, you should score. Odds are, you will notice the Yankees leaving a lot of “supposed to score” runs on the table. That may be fine in a 162-game season, but it could very well be deadly in a short playoff series.

Game #128: Soriano Blows It

Bad loss. Bad Loss. BAD LOSS.

Exactly a month before last night’s debacle of an 8-7, 11-inning loss to the lowly Blue Jays, I wrote the following about so-called Bad Losses:

The critical part of a Bad Loss is an abject failure of execution. Sometime it’s an error at the worst time, sometimes it’s a manager playing what appears to be Hungry Hungry Hippos with his bullpen moves. Either way, the loss can linger for days, weeks or even an entire season.

“Abject failure of execution” is a perfect way to describe what Rafael Soriano did against Rajai Davis and Colby Rasmus last night. With a man on and two outs in the ninth, Soriano got ahead of Davis 0-2. The Yankee Stadium crowd rose to its feet for a game-ending cheer, and the Yankees prepared to savor a hard-fought 6-4 win.

(Since I’m about to excoriate Soriano, I should point out that he has saved 33 of 36 chances since stepping in for Mariano Rivera. That said, his performance on and off the field last night was so atrocious that he deserves what’s coming to him.)

At this point, Soriano had at least one and possibly two pitches to waste. His slider was not breaking well, and Davis had barely missed an 0-1 hanging slider, fouling it off. But Davis was champing at the bit to swing, and Soriano had only to put a pitch in the dirt, or at his ankles, and the game would be over. Before the 0-2 pitch, Russell Martin actually motioned toward the ground with his glove and then set the glove about six inches off the ground, the equivalent of a neon sign reminding Soriano to PUT IT IN THE DIRT.

Instead, the Yankee closer threw yet another hanging slider at the belt, and Davis slapped it through the hole into left field for a single. Missing that badly on an 0-2 pitch is inexcusable at any point in a game, but it can be deadly for a temperamental closer like Soriano**, who was clearly rattled as Rasmus came to the plate. Two pitches later, Rasmus crushed another hanging slider into the second deck in right field, and justlikethat it was 7-6 Toronto.

**Soriano left the clubhouse after the game without speaking to reporters, a move he pulled before with the Yankees early last season. I won’t belabor this point because it’s moot right now, but… would Mariano Rivera EVER blow off the press after blowing a game? This guy agrees with me.

The Yankees tied the game in the bottom of the ninth on a home run by Derek Jeter, who continues to party like it’s 1999. But they couldn’t push across another run, and a throwing error by Derek Lowe in the 11th set up an RBI groundout that gave the Blue Jays the win. Abject failure of execution, indeed.

After the sordid finish, we learned that Mark Teixeira suffered a Grade 1 left calf strain during the game and will miss 1-3 weeks. It’s the same injury Jeter had last June, and he missed exactly three weeks. Nick Swisher has filled in adequately for Teixeira at first, and new pickup Steve Pearce can spot Swish at times. But the injury leaves a gaping hole in the Yankee lineup, which currently looks something like this:

1. Derek Jeter
2. Nick Swisher
3. Robinson Cano
4. Eric Chavez/Curtis Granderson
5. Granderson/Chavez
6. Andruw Jones
7. Jayson Nix/Casey McGehee (gulp)
8. Ichiro
9. Russell Martin

That’s a terrible lineup once you get past the top five — only Ichiro has had any recent success among the guys in the bottom four spots. The Yanks will need all the pitching they can get to hold off the Rays and Orioles with Teix, A-Rod and Andy Pettitte injured. And they certainly can’t afford another Bad Loss like Soriano’s implosion last night.

Games #125-127: Winning Without Hitting

After a grisly sweep at the hands of the White Sox cut the Yankees’ AL East to just 2.5 games over the sizzling Rays, the Bombers got back some breathing room by taking two of three from the Indians. Despite the series win, the Yankees continue to display frightening levels of incompetence at the plate. In three games against Cleveland and their 4.77 team ERA (third-worst in the MLB), the Yanks managed a total of eight runs. Let’s go game-by-game.

(more…)

Game #104: Wins > Injuries

Where was I? Oh yeah, Ivan Nova’s remarkably self-serving postgame comments and his precipitous fall in the Yankee rotation. Well after Tuesday’s debacle, the Yanks desperately needed an easy win to right the ship and keep a healthy distance between themselves and the Orioles in the AL East.

(more…)

Game #102: A Rough Bronx Night

Before I go all Dan Shaughnessy on you, let me stipulate that every team, no matter how good, has a rough stretch during a baseball season. There are 162 games, so it’s inevitable. Even the 1998 Yankees, the best team I’ve ever seen, lost six of eight games from Aug. 19-26. It’s counter-productive to get worked up about a bad two weeks for your favorite baseball team, because that fortnight represents about 8% of the season.

With that said…

(more…)

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.